R1G1 RECAP: Nutshell. Isles Drop Pens 4-3 in OT feat. Alice in Chains

R1G1 RECAP: Nutshell. Isles Drop Pens 4-3 in OT feat. Alice in Chains


R1G1 RECAP: Nutshell. Isles Drop Pens 4-3 in OT feat. Alice in Chains


It’s been 19 days since my last blog.  Big mountain-standard time zone swing through Yellowstone, Bozeman, and shit.

Huge thanks to my Pensblog counterparts and DOZENS of readers for bearing with me during the totally unearned hiatus.

It appears three (3) things happened while I was gone:

  1. Tom Wilson further challenged Donald Bren for most impressive billion-dollar real estate empire.  Following last weeks’ Rangers series, Zillow estimates showed TW43 LLC as the sole proprietor of approximately 89% of all beachfront property in the heads of very serious hockey people across all corners of the internet.
  2. The Penguins made the playoffs (fantastic) and won the division (who cares), earning a first-round date with the notoriously pesky Barry Trotz Islanders.  I feel like people are *way* too excited about this.
  3. Jeff Carter continues to be a great Father to Geoff, but we all kind of want a piece of that juicy sack.

If you’re like me, you’ve probably outgrown Barstool (with the exception of Spittin Chiclets, which is objectively good hockey content). However, I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention what a lazy, talentless asshole their Islanders “personality” is.  I only bring it up because the guy’s dad owns a restaurant in Long Island that has become a bit of a symbol for Islanders playoff runs.  The problem is, the place SUCKS.  Don’t take my word for it.

The point of all this?  Everything about the Islanders, their fans, and Nassau Coliseum are just like this restaurant.  Gross.  Soggy.  Awful.  Disgusting.  Yuck.  Slimy.  Low quality.

At least the Coliseum knows when to call it quits.  This will be the last year for that piece of shit building, and here’s hoping the Pens can be the ones to close the doors for good.  Maybe that restaurant can be next.

Fuck these guys.  CAP:


Two elite tone-setting shifts for the Crosby line through the first 4 minutes.  Isles looked overwhelmed but finally got a shot on net around the 5 minute mark.

Rust almost had a breakaway chance.  Tang broke up a 2-on-1.  Mostly all Pens, which is why what happened next was about as surprising as John Mulaney’s next relapse.

NYI GOAL – Palmieri (1) A: Dobson, JGP [7:58] 1-0 NYI

Jars probably shouldn’t duck out of the way of pucks, but whatever.  The goal didn’t seem to bother the Penguins, who just kept churning the legs.

Eventually, Brendan Burke called Frederick Gaudreau “Johnny” during a shift, which Freddy G was understandably upset about considering he is like 9 inches taller than Johnny and also in the playoffs.

He took it out on Islanders goalie Aaron Sorkin, who was busy writing some Jesse Eisenberg movie with edgy, unrealistic dialogue.

PIT GOAL – Gaudreau (1) A: E-Rod [11:10] 1-1

Love that bench punch.

A bit later, Clutterbuck found himself on a breakaway following a botched dump-in by Dumo.  Cluts proceeded to botch the chance, missing high.  Just an all-around Botch Job.

In a sequence that felt like a DMT trip, Beauvillier whiffed on a puck in front of a wide-open net, leading to a breakout pass to a streaking Guentzel the other way.  The pass was a way ahead of Jake, but instead of harmlessly playing it before 59 could get there, Sorokin allowed it to get all the way to the goal line, then tripped Guentzel.

Bizarre (and dangerous) decision that gave the Pens their 1st PP of the series. Pens were in the zone the entire 2 minutes but couldn’t get one to go.  Cros almost caused WW3 with a tip-in as it was expiring.

No more blood as we went to intermission.


Jarry with a nice toe-save to start the period before the Guins settled in for some excellent shifts.  Blueger and E-Rod were making life miserable for the Isles.  It was like that scene from Christmas story.

Isles thought their work was finished when 53/9 left the ice, but unfortunately for them, the Crosby line was next.  Didn’t take long.

PIT GOAL – Crosby (1) A: Dumo, Guentzel [3.47] 2-1 PIT

Crosby blew past the “What else can you say about him?” level some time during the Obama administration, so this is really just more of the same ridiculousness.  An impossible one-handed tip like that has become almost routine. It’s a joke.

Pens had a PP somewhere but didn’t convert.  The kill settled New York down a bit as the pace became a little less lopsided.

The next-best chance for either team came around the 12 minute mark with a Guentzel/Crosby 2-on-1, but they couldn’t cash.

Mr. Carter high-sticked Brock Nelson, causing him to bleed his own blood.  The Pens proceeded to execute a game-defining 4-minute kill. The Isles PP looked as useful as Anne Frank’s drum kit.

With a shade over 2 minutes left, Andy Greene interfered with Mr. Carter, sending the Pens to a PP for basically the balance of the period.  It looked like shit, so we’d go to intermission expecting an ass-clench 3rd which almost certainly would include an Isles power play or two.


Isles goal was the first notable thing to happen in the period.  Fuck.

NYI GOAL – JGP (1) A: Mayfield [3:33] 2-2

People hate Keith Jones.  Seems a little harsh to me, but there’s no denying he’s mostly a vanilla wafer.  That said, he nailed it when implying that Jarry’s great saves in this game don’t erase the fact that both goals allowed were dog shit (paraphrasing here).

Pens’ eggs were scrambled for the next 5-10 minutes as the Isles poured on the chances.  They appeared to be hanging on for dear life, sort of like the buttons on a Sofia Vergara top.

Thank you for letting me shoehorn in this week’s shameless clickbait gif. You can always count on me for at least one.

The most noteworthy thing to happen before the 5 minute mark was Dumo taking a nasty slapper off the foot.  He appeared to be in significant pain, but came back.  Something to keep an eye on knowing how this finish-the-game-then-scratched-shit goes.

With 4:10 to go, the Isles took the lead on a Brock Nelson shot that Jarry probably should have saved.  Again.

NYI GOAL – Nelson (1) A: Beauvillier, Pulock [15:50] 3-2 NYI

Luckily, the pride of Jim Rutherford wasn’t ready to go down without a fight.

PIT GOAL – Kapanen (1) A: Carter, Ceci [16:21] 3-3

Don’t get it twisted.  To release a laser like that, right after a backbreaking goal, in that spot…that guy is a player.  Big brass balls, babe.

All I remember from the last five minutes is explaining to my girlfriend how I was going to fix the hole in the wall.  Playoff hockey.


Barzal nearly put my father Matheson on a poster about 2 minutes into the OT frame, but McCann bailed him out on the backcheck just before he got a shot off.

The Crosby line turned up the pressure about 10 minutes in, but Dumo took a risky pinch on the same shift leading to a terrifying Eberle/Barzal 2-on-1.  Letang made a phenomenal breakup to neutralize the threat.

Sometimes even a son must condemn his own Father.  Just ask Jonathan Moxon.

I must do the same.  Completely unacceptable, laughable turnover by Matheson in his own zone, but Jarry bailed him out.  Should have been the game, but we played on.

A couple minutes later, Carter won a puck race to the front of the net, forcing Sorokin to make a point-blank save.

But that would be the Pens best chance.  They just looked fucking sloppy and eventually the levy broke.  It was Caterpillar Eyebrows Palmieri.

NYI GOAL – Palmieri (2) Unassisted [16:30] 4-3 NYI



  • I’ve been a “don’t worry about the goaltending” guy all year, but need a better performance from Jarry.  At least 2 of those goals should be saved, probably three.
  • Pens lost this game by not converting on their early PP chances and letting the pesky Barry Trotz Islanders hang around despite “dominating” the game’s first 2 periods “analytically”.  I have said it 8 million times before and will do so again.  There is more than one way to skin a cat and win playoff games.  Just because a style isn’t fun to watch doesn’t mean it won’t work, especially over a small sample size.  We have seen this fish before.  Adjust or die.
  • Was good to see Tanev back in the lineup, his energy is what you need this time of year.  But I’m sure someone will produce a pie chart indicating that he actually sucked.
  • Crosby continues to get abused and produce anyway.  Doesn’t seem like he minds, so neither should you.
  • Zucker – do more.
  • Win Tuesday and all is forgiven.  The key will be goaltending and opportunity.  That’s the playoffs in a Nutshell.
  • Let’s exchange insults on Twitter @GooeyHockey


 Nick Leddy #2 of the New York Islanders checks Jake Guentzel #59 of the Pittsburgh Penguins in Game One of the First Round of the 2021 Stanley Cup Playoffs at PPG PAINTS Arena on May 16, 2021 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Joe Sargent/NHLI via Getty Images)


More Sports

More Penguins