Hall of Fame Questions

With Curt Schilling’s retirement announcement comes questions on his Hall of Fame chances. The here are a few of the opinions from around the web:

The Bulletin – Philadelphia:

Based on his regular-season numbers, Schilling falls short of Cooperstown status. His 216 wins rank 80th on the all-time list. To put that in perspective, some of the names around him are Kenny Rogers (219), Charlie Hough (216) and Kevin Brown (211). Not exactly plaque-worthy, are they?……But Schilling’s career was about more than just statistics. It was about impact, how one pitcher influenced three different franchises in a major way….
He won’t be a first-ballot Hall of Famer, but he’ll find his way into Cooperstown eventually. Because in baseball, more than any other sport, mediocre seasons here and there are forgotten over time.

True greatness, on the other hand, lives on forever

.

Washington Post:

But he was great theater any time he took the mound, and for a stretch of nearly a decade (roughly 1997-2006), he was one of the top half-dozen pitchers in the game. Take all that, and add the October heroics, and Schilling starts to look pretty Hall-worthy.

ESPN – Rob Neyer:

Two years I was lukewarm about Schilling’s Hall of Fame candidacy. I wasn’t against it, exactly. But neither was I for it. But during those two years, Schilling helped pitch the Red Sox to another championship and I got just a little bit smarter. Today I can’t imagine a Hall of Fame without him.

Schilling brought hope to Boston the moment he started filming his Dunkin’ Donuts commercials by wearing his “Why not us?” t-shirt. He was the keystone to the 2004 and 2007 seasons, without him the Red Sox Nation might still be talking about a curse. No matter what you think about his politics, he is the guy you wanted to have on the mound against the Yankees; he was no Pedro when it came to silencing opposing fans. He deserves a spot in the Hall and needs to be wearing a Sox cap when he goes.