2018 All-Money Team: The Highest-Paid MLB Players at Each Position

MLB: World Series-Houston Astros at Los Angeles Dodgers

The MLB offseason was incredibly slow. How slow was it, exactly? Well, we didn’t see a free agent sign a $100-plus million contract until the calendar flipped to February. However, there are still plenty of dudes that’ll make bank in 2018.

If a lot of the below players being on this list sounds familiar, that’s because quite a few were also on it entering the 2017 season. Many of them are getting ready for this year in a bit of a different situation based on their most recent production, though.

According to Spotrac’s payroll salary rankings, the following 11 ballplayers all have the honor of bringing home the most bacon at their respective positions by the time October rolls around.

Catcher: Buster Posey, San Francisco Giants

2018 Salary: $22.178 million

When using wRC+ as the barometer, the Giants had baseball’s worst offense in 2017. Nobody can blame Buster Posey for this offensive ineptitude, though. The veteran backstop slashed a very healthy .320/.400/.462 in 568 plate appearances last season, and led the squad rather handily in metrics like OPS (.861), wOBA (.366), wRC+ (128), and fWAR (4.3).

It is worth noting that Posey’s power numbers have consistently declined since 2014. Here’s a look at how his home-run production and ISO have progressed.

2014 605 22 .179
2015 623 19 .153
2016 614 14 .147
2017 568 12 .142

His batted-ball profile took a step forward this past year after taking a step backward in 2016, but his 33.0% hard-hit rate was the lowest it’s been since 2013. What is encouraging, though, is that his hard-hit rate on fly balls last year was 46.9% (second-highest mark of his career), while his 7.7% soft-hit rate was the second-best mark of his career.

First Base: Miguel Cabrera, Detroit Tigers

2018 Salary: $30 million

Just about anyway you slice it, last year was the worst of Miguel Cabrera’s career. Him dealing with a back injury that could very well impact him for the remainder of his career won’t help things, either. Just about everyone knew his current contract — which will pay him $30-plus million each year through 2023 (his age-40 season) would not end well. It just seemed to happen very quickly.

With all that in mind, why is there reason to believe he’s not done yet? Entering his age-35 campaign, it’d be unfair to expect the Miggy of old, but there were some encouraging peripherals to consider — his .292 BABIP was a career-low mark (.344 for his career) despite a career-high 27.3% line-drive rate and a 42.5% hard-hit rate that still ranked among the best in baseball.

Cabrera could be on the downturn of his career after such consistently elite production, but there’s at least a glimmer of hope that he’s got something left in his tank.

Second Base: Robinson Cano, Seattle Mariners

2018 Salary: $24 million

Like Cabrera, Robinson Cano is also under contract until 2023. While he produced better than Miggy at the plate in 2017, it was still a step back from the year prior.

The veteran second baseman was a prime regression candidate heading into last season since his home-run production (39) was higher than his fly-ball rate (36.1%), which led to a homer-to-fly-ball ratio of 19.3% that was the second-highest of his career. That ratio dropped to 14.7% this past year — right in line with his 14.5% career mark — but it was also accompanied by a sharp drop in fly-ball rate (30.6%) and rise in ground-ball rate (50.0%).

Of the four seasons he’s been in Seattle, Cano has produced a ground-ball rate below 50.0% just once. He began his career with a three-year stretch like this, but had limited his grounders below that number for six consecutive years before leaving the Bronx via free agency.

Shortstop: Troy Tulowitzki, Toronto Blue Jays

2018 Salary: $20 million

This is slowly turning into a sad list, but that’s what can potentially happen on the second half of these lucrative long-term deals.

Injuries have always been a problem for Troy Tulowitzki — after all, he hasn’t played in more than 131 games in a season since 2011. He was limited to just 260 plate appearances (66 games) in 2017, and it resulted in a lackluster .249/.300/.378 triple slash to go along with an equally sad .292 wOBA and 78 wRC+.

There are a number of troubling numbers when looking through Tulo’s profile, but if healthy, he’d really benefit from getting off to a decent start. In his two full seasons with Toronto, the 33-year-old posted a 67 wRC+ in April of 2016 and a 73 wRC+ in April of 2017.

Third Base: Josh Donaldson, Toronto Blue Jays

2018 Salary: $23 million

Josh Donaldson is different from just about all of the guys in this group for a couple reasons: he’s likely headed for free agency next winter, and he hasn’t gotten the huge payday everyone else has already received.

Although his 2017 season was also limited by injury — he accumulated 496 plate appearances in only 113 games — check out how consistent he’s been since landing in Toronto in 2015.

2015 71 .939 .271 41 123 .398 154 8.8
2016 700 .953 .265 37 99 .403 155 7.6
2017 496 .944 .289 33 78 .396 149 5.0

Let’s also not forget that Donaldson won American League MVP honors for his dominant 2015 season. So he’s been hitting at an MVP level for three years in a row.

If he does make it to the open market, his case will be an interesting one to follow since he’ll be entering his age-33 campaign.

2018 All-Money Team: The Highest-Paid MLB Players at Each Position

Left Field: Yoenis Cespedes, New York Mets

2018 Salary: $29 million

The biggest X-factor for Yoenis Cespedes in 2018 is whether or not he can stay on the field. Leg injuries have led to multiple stints on the disabled list since his first full season in New York in 2016, but he’s hoping some yoga will change that.

While he only stepped to the plate 321 times last year, it’s worth noting that his power and overall offensive numbers were basically the same. His .247 ISO, .369 wOBA, and 131 wRC+ are almost identical to how he produced between 2015 and 2016 combined (.251 ISO, .368 wOBA, and 135 wRC+).

It’s also worth noting that after he nearly doubled his walk rate between 2015 (4.9%) and 2016 (9.4%), that adjustment held true in 2017 with an 8.1% mark. The potential for more power is also there, as his 49.6% fly-ball rate and 42.2% hard-hit rate are both single-season career-bests.

Center Field: Mike Trout, Los Angeles Angels

2018 Salary: $34.08 million

It took a while, but the best position player in baseball is finally the highest-paid position player, too.

The 2017 season marked the first time we saw Mike Trout hit the disabled list, and it was a shame because he was on pace to do some special things. He still managed to enjoy his fourth season of 30-plus homers, fourth 20-20 performance (second in a row), and career-highs in both wOBA (.437) and wRC+ (181).

Trout’s plate discipline has also been on an upward trend. After posting an 11.8% walk rate and 26.1% strikeout rate (a career-worst mark) in 2014, each of those numbers have improved with each following season. Those improvements culminated in 2017 with a walk rate (18.5%) that outpaced his strikeout rate (17.8%).

Right Field: Jason Heyward, Chicago Cubs

2018 Salary: $28.17 million

Technically speaking, Jason Heyward’s offense improved last year, but it’s mostly because it couldn’t have gotten much worse compared to his 2016 performance. It still wasn’t that great, though.

In 481 plate appearances, the right fielder posted a .715 OPS with a .130 ISO, .311 wOBA, and 88 wRC+. This was also the second consecutive year that Heyward’s soft-hit rate (25.7%) was higher than his hard-hit rate (25.5%).

He did win his fourth consecutive Gold Glove award, but his overall performance led to just 0.9 fWAR. He’s racked up just 2.4 total fWAR in two years with the Cubs, which still doesn’t equal any fWAR he posted during a single season between 2012 and 2015.

Designated Hitter: Albert Pujols, Los Angeles Angels

2018 Salary: $27 million

When Miguel Cabrera and Albert Pujols both land on the same list, we’re normally singing their praises. Not this time around, and it just feels wrong.

If fWAR is our barometer, Pujols was the worst position player in baseball last year among qualified hitters. He wasn’t as bad if we’re solely looking at offensive production and ranking players by wRC+, but his mark of 78 was still among the worst. He’s racking up counting stats — the right-handed slugger collected 23 homers and 101 RBI in 2017 — but that’s pretty much only because of the volume of plate appearances he received.

With Shohei Ohtani now in the fold for Los Angeles, Pujols will also be playing first base a little more often, a position he’s only manned for 283.1 innings over the last two years. That’ll take a physical toll on him, but there’s hope he can bounce back a bit since this winter was finally one that didn’t involve any kind of rehab.

Starting Pitcher: Clayton Kershaw, Los Angeles Dodgers

2018 Salary: $35.57 million

Clayton Kershaw has been at the top of the food chain with regard to yearly pitcher earnings for quite some time, but he’s been worth it literally every single year.

Posting 4.6 fWAR through 175 innings last season is valuable to any team, but it’s a slight step back from what he had been doing recently — which is a testament to just how nasty he’s been. His 2.31 ERA and 3.04 SIERA were both his highest marks since 2012 (2.53 ERA, 3.31 SIERA), while his 29.8% strikeout rate failed to finish above 30.0% for the first time since 2013.

What is also worth pointing out is the performance of his curveball. Between 2012 and 2016, opposing hitters posted a negative wRC+ on that offering. In 2017, though, that number settled in at 27.

Like we said before, Kershaw is still filthy — he just wasn’t as filthy as we’ve seen in recent years.

Relief Pitcher: Aroldis Chapman, New York Yankees

2018 Salary: $20 million

When looking at his season-long numbers, it’s easy to think that Aroldis Chapman took a step back. If we just look at his performances since 2012, the 3.22 ERA, 2.97 SIERA, 32.9% strikeout rate, and 1.6 fWAR he just posted were all the worst they’ve been. Most of this can be attributed to a rough month of August, when he posted a 9.00 ERA, 21.1% strikeout rate, 15.8% walk rate, and .400 wOBA allowed in eight innings of work.

This is obviously a small sample size, but when you only throw 50.1 innings throughout the entire year, it ends up being a big deal.

He turned things around quickly in September, though. His final 12 regular-season innings included a 0.00 ERA, 41.5% strikeout rate, 4.9% walk rate, and .107 wOBA allowed. When we pair that with a 1.13 ERA (1.28 SIERA), 48.5% strikeout rate, and 6.1% walk rate through eight playoff innings, it seems like he’ll be just fine moving forward.

2018 All-Money Team: The Highest-Paid MLB Players at Each PositionAbout Matt Musico

Matt Musico currently manages Chin Music Baseball and contributes to The Sports Daily. His past work has been featured at numberFire, Yahoo! Sports and Bleacher Report. He’s also written a book about how to become a sports blogger. You can sign up for his email newsletter here.

2018 All-Money Team: The Highest-Paid MLB Players at Each Position Email 2018 All-Money Team: The Highest-Paid MLB Players at Each Position Twitter

Arrow to top