A Look at MLS Playoff Tiebreakers

We are into the final three months of the 2012 MLS season and the conference races are heating up. Each conference is afforded five spots, allowing 10 of the 19 MLS teams into the playoffs. Over the last two seasons, the playoff format has changed, going from eight teams to ten, adding wild card teams and taking them away. Gone are the days of a team on the east coast making a run through the western ranks to win the western conference championship. The format also allows for teams to have less travel through the playoffs. This year, fans are guaranteed a west versus east MLS Cup final, hosted by the team with the better record.

 

Before the season started, the MLS Board of Governors met and decided on the new tiebreaker rules in case teams are tied at the end of the regular season.

1. Goals For

Eastern Conference

Western Conference

New York

38

San Jose

45

Houston

35

LA Galaxy

39

DC United

35

Real Salt Lake

35

Montreal

35

Seattle

31

Sporting KC

28

Colorado

29

New England

26

Vancouver

26

Chicago

25

FC Dallas

26

Toronto FC

25

Portland

20

Philadelphia

22

Chivas USA

14

Columbus

20

 

2. Goal Differential

Eastern Conference

Western Conference

Houston

10

San Jose

17

DC United

8

Seattle

9

Sporting KC

7

Real Salt Lake

7

New York

4

LA Galaxy

0

Chicago

1

Vancouver

-2

Columbus

-1

Colorado

-3

Philadelphia

-2

FC Dallas

-6

New England

-2

Chivas USA

-7

Montreal

-8

Portland

-17

Toronto FC

-15

 

3. Fewest Disciplinary Points

Eastern Conference

Western Conference

New England

275

Chivas USA

319

DC United

292

Colorado

324

Houston

305

Portland

348

Columbus

317

FC Dallas

377

Chicago

322

Seattle

390

Toronto FC

339

San Jose

404

New York

368

LA Galaxy

405

Philadelphia

370

Vancouver

416

Sporting KC

382

Real Salt Lake

420

Montreal

 

4. Road Goals

Eastern Conference

Western Conference

Sporting KC

16

LA Galaxy

20

New York

16

San Jose

19

Houston

14

Seattle

15

Toronto FC

14

Real Salt Lake

12

DC United

11

FC Dallas

12

Chicago

10

Vancouver

9

Montreal

10

Chivas USA

8

New England

10

Colorado

8

Columbus

8

Portland

2

Philadelphia

6

 

5. Road Goal Differential

Eastern Conference

Western Conference

Sporting KC

2

San Jose

4

Columbus

-2

Seattle

0

Houston

-4

Chivas USA

-2

Chicago

-4

LA Galaxy

-3

DC United

-7

Real Salt Lake

-4

New York

-8

Vancouver

-8

Philadelphia

-8

FC Dallas

-9

New England

-8

Colorado

-11

Toronto FC

-8

Portland

-18

Montreal

-16

 

6. Home Goals

Eastern Conference

Games Played

Montreal

25

13

DC United

24

11

New York

22

10

Houston

21

11

Philadelphia

16

10

New England

16

11

Chicago

15

11

Sporting KC

12

11

Columbus

12

9

Toronto FC

11

11

Western Conference
San Jose 26 11
Real Salt Lake 23 13
Colorado 21 12
LA Galaxy 19 11
Portland 18 12
Vancouver 17 11
Seattle 16 11
FC Dallas 14 13
Chivas USA 6 11

 

7. Home Goal Differential

Eastern Conference

Western Conference

DC United

15

San Jose

13

Houston

14

Real Salt Lake

11

New York

12

Seattle

9

Montreal

8

Colorado

8

Philadelphia

6

Vancouver

6

New England

6

LA Galaxy

3

Sporting KC

5

Portland

1

Chicago

5

Chivas

-5

Columbus

1

FC Dallas

-7

Toronto FC

-7

 

8. Coin Toss (between 2 teams) or Drawing of Lots (3 or more teams)

With these new rules, MLS seems to be rewarding teams for good behavior on the field as well as teams who don’t form a defensive shell when on the road.

The MLS playoffs start on October 31st and if the season ended today they would see the fourth and fifth place teams in each conference facing off in a one game match. DC United (4) would host the Chicago Fire (5) in the east and Vancouver (4) would host defending MLS Cup champions LA Galaxy (5). The east winner would go on to face the Houston Dynamo and the west winner would face Supporter Shield leaders San Jose. New York (3) would host Sporting KC (2) and Seattle (3) would host Real Salt Lake (2) to start the home and home quarterfinals.

Arrow to top