Derek Roy vs Tim Connolly

Derek Roy vs Tim Connolly

I don’t pretend to be the biggest hockey guru this side of the American Border, but what I do know is the way to build a great hockey team is right down the middle. You need centerman. Gretzky and Messier, Yzerman and Federov, Crosby and Malkin. The list goes on and on for Stanley Cup winning teams having elite centers.

The Sabres had that duo 3 years ago. I know some of you Sabres apologists hate when Drury and Briere are brought up. But the bottom line is the success of the Sabres during that time was because of the depth they had at center.

Since Drury and Briere left, the Sabres have tried to pass the torch to Derek Roy and Tim Connolly. I won’t say they’ve failed, but they sure as hell haven’t come close to filling their predecessor’s shoes.

I’ve been very critical of the Sabres brass over the months since writing this blog. But, if I were to pick players on this team who have pissed me off or left me amazed at their talent, it’s Connolly and Roy.

Lets start with Derek Roy. Roy is starting to become the Miro Satan and Alexander Mogilny of the team amongst the fans. Sure, he scores a lot of goals but there are just things he does that make you want to pull your hair out. For one thing, he dives…constantly! And even if diving wasn’t called a penalty in the NHL, it rubs me the wrong way that Roy isn’t fighting enough to make a play. It shows weakness.

Secondly, Roy doesn’t get dirty enough when he’s in front of the net. Roy normally likes to camp out at least 10-12 feet in front of the net. That’s not good enough. He needs to be on top of the goalie. Roy doesn’t have the blistering shot to just sit by the face off circle. 

Breire and Drury were great, because they were able to score anywhere on the ice. Roy needs to adapt that philosophy. 

Another popular knock on Roy is his lifestyle. Look, every fan always fantasizes about what life would be like if they were an athlete. Partying sure as hell would be at the top of my list of things to do. When I was living in Buffalo, I would always see the Sabres players at the bars throwing down beers like it was Gatorade. I even one time saw one Sabre carrying another Sabre over his back while taking him to his car. In other words, everyone does it. 

Roy maybe the Satan and Mogilny of the team, but Tim Connolly is becoming the Rob Johnson version of hockey. Remember how Johnson would have all the talent in the world, but he just couldn’t stay healthy. 

I feel fans fall way to much in love with Connolly’s skills (like they did for Johnson) and don’t realize he’s done very little in his NHL career. The stats don’t lie. 18 goals is his career high and he hasn’t played more than 50 games since 2005-2006 season. And the injuries this guy nurses are for ballerina dancers. 
To make matters worse the dude got a 20% raise after playing just 1/3 of his games over the past 3 years. The reason Connolly gets chance after chance is because Darcy Reiger is hell bent on proving people wrong that his Peca for Connolly deal was legit. 
So now that we have the tale of the tape out of the way, what’s the final verdict? Derek Roy. I feel Roy still has a lot of bad habits that can be cleaned up. Remember Daniel Briere use to be the same way when he started out with the Coyotes and got taken to task by Lindy Ruff. As for Connolly, I just can’t get past the injuries. Sure he’s got a ton of talent, but what’s the use if the dude can barley play half the season. 
Arrow to top