10 MLB free agents in 2020 facing make-or-break years

MLB: San Francisco Giants at St. Louis Cardinals

Josh Donaldson, Atlanta Braves

The changes in how MLB teams value players, combined with Josh Donaldson’s age (33) and injury history instantly makes him an intriguing free-agent case study. Not necessarily for this past winter, though. It wasn’t surprising that he signed with the Braves for a one-year deal following a season in which he was limited to just 52 games and 219 plate appearances.

The $23 million he’ll receive was probably a little surprising, but Donaldson is likely hoping there’s more where that came from if he can re-establish value with Atlanta.

While his 1.3 fWAR between the Toronto Blue Jays and Cleveland Indians was a clear step down from the previous five years (at least 5.1 fWAR each year from 2013-17), a lot of his rate stats didn’t take drastic drops. His strikeout rate has spiked, but his walk rate (14.2%) and other plate-discipline numbers stayed on par with career norms.

Donaldson’s .203 ISO was a definite step down, but he managed to do that despite a 47.8% ground-ball rate and 35.1% fly-ball rate, both career-worst marks if sustained over a full season. His 41.0% hard-hit rate is encouraging, though. It’s up to the veteran third baseman to prove he’s still one of the game’s top sluggers. Getting a long-term deal will be difficult regardless of his performance, but a rebound resembling some of his earlier work in Toronto would certainly help.

Arrow to top