Manning the greatest?

Tip to Bobeo and Westside Rob, I wasn’t going to link to this piece for two reasons:

1.  I’m no fan of Bleacher Report

2.  This piece tries to blame Marvin for the Colts postseason failures.  Frankly that makes no sense, especially not when you go back and look at each game.  That argument annoys me so much that I was going to just let the pice go.

But since two different readers have asked me to link it up, I will.

Is Manning the greatest ever?

Peyton Manning (Post-Season Career)

435 of 692 (62.9) for 5,164 yards, 28 touchdowns and 19 interceptions.

QB rating: 87.6

Surprising production for a post-season choke artist; but he’s still no Tom Brady…

Tom Brady (Post-Season Career)

395 of 637 (62.0) for 4,108 yards, 28 touchdowns and 15 interceptions.

QB rating: 85.5

Wait a second!

That can’t be right; Tom Brady has the best post-season winning percentage in NFL history. He can’t be out-produced by the league’s most infamous choke artist!

But nevertheless, that’s the reality.

Arrow to top