Tanier explains Philly

A wonderful read from an 18to88 friend.

Most cities would treasure Mike Schmidt, a three-time most valuable player who led the Phillies to their first World Series title. Philly old-timers, however, swear that Schmidt stank in the clutch, his 548 home runs somehow producing only 274 runs batted in.

Philly fans preferred Greg Luzinski, a portly slugger who played left field like a brontosaurus flailing in a tar pit. Schmidt was aloof and sensitive, Luzinski flabby and fun. Schmidt was a proto A-Rod, but Alex Rodriquez is held to the standards of Ruth and Mantle, and Schmidt could not win fans’ hearts away from Johnny Callison.

Arrow to top