This shouldn’t be a problem! (must read)

Kuharsky nails it.

So the time difference we are talking about is the time it takes the umpire to clear a linebacker 3 or 5 yards away and the time it takes the umpire to clear a running back 6 or 7 yards away. That shouldn’t be major, should it?

I’m not a mathemagician, but I think the difference in those equations is being exaggerated.

Yes, it’s an alteration that it’s happening over a signal-caller’s shoulder as opposed to right in front of him, but it’s an adjustment that can be made. I bet it won’t be long before QBs can sense when the ump is clear or it’s second nature to peripherally see the hand signal from an official on the sideline.

On one other element being debated here: I agree with Bill Polian that calling a 5-yard penalty for an illegal snap is excessive. If the quarterback is too quick and the play is blown dead because the umpire wasn’t sufficiently backed out, the stoppage of play amounts to enough of a penalty for the offense.

Spot the ball again with as little delay as possible, get the umpire out and let the offense get right back to work.

 

Arrow to top