2024 NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds, Picks, and Winners

The NFL Comeback Player of the Year Award is handed out to the player that has displayed perseverance in overcoming adversity.

Oftentimes, NFL Comeback Player of the Year Award candidates are returning from injury, rebounding from a poor performance, or were out of the league altogether in the previous season.

To learn more about the award, including the top contenders for the 2022 NFL Comeback Player of the Year Award, read on below.

The Best Online Sportsbooks for NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds

$1,000 Sportsbook Bonus + 3 Free Bets
Claim Offer
$750 Welcome Bonus Offer
Claim Offer
$750 Sports Betting Offer + 4 Free Bets of $100
Claim Offer
$1,000 Sports Betting Bonus
Claim Offer
125% Welcome Bonus Worth Up To $2,500
Claim Offer
15% Cashback for the First 7 Days
Claim Now

NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds

There are a number of high-profile NFL Comeback Player of the Year candidates in 2022, as many players fit the criteria for the award this season.

According to the best NFL betting sites, Saquon Barkley leads the pack with the best odds to win Comeback Player of the Year with +250 odds. Barkley’s career has been riddled with injuries and he is coming off a torn ACL he suffered in Week 3 in the 2020 season.

Meanwhile, Lamar Jackson (+350) and Christian McCaffrey (+500) sit closely behind on the Comeback Player of the Year odds board.

McCaffrey makes his return after only playing 10 games in the last two seasons. When he isn’t injured, McCaffrey is one of the most dominant players in the NFL.

Brian Robinson will also draw attention as he recovers from getting shot in the leg following a carjacking incident.

While he hasn’t played for the Washington Commanders yet, his story will garner Comeback Player of the Year buzz when he does return to the field.

Check out the chart below for the best NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds from BetOnline, one of the best offshore sports betting sites.

Comeback Player of the Year Odds Play
Saquon Barkley -210 BetOnline logo
Geno Smith +500 BetOnline logo
Christian McCaffrey +1200 BetOnline logo
Lamar Jackson +1200 BetOnline logo
Derrick Henry +1400 BetOnline logo
Daniel Jones +2000 BetOnline logo
JK Dobbins +3300 BetOnline logo
Jameis Winston +5000 BetOnline logo
Michael Thomas +5500 BetOnline logo
JuJu Smith-Schuster +6600 BetOnline logo
Khalil Mack +6600 BetOnline logo
Travis Etienne +7500 BetOnline logo
Marcus Mariota +7500 BetOnline logo
Danielle Hunter +8000 BetOnline logo
Branndon Graham +10000 BetOnline logo

2022 NFL Comeback Player of the Year Candidates

The 2022 NFL season is full of worthy Comeback Player of the Year candidates.

While there are many heart warming comeback journeys, the award is generally presented to a player that has overcome adversity from severe injury or poor performance from the previous season.

The NFL has been back for two weeks and the 2022 NFL Comeback Player of the Year conversation is centered around three running backs in Saquon Barkley, Chrisitan McCaffrey and Derrick Henry

Check out the table below for the best Comeback Player of the Year candidates for the 2022 NFL season.

Rank NFL Comeback Player of the Year Candidates Odds
1 Saquon Barkley -210
2 Geno Smith +500
3 Christian McCaffrey +1200
4 Lamar Jackson +1200
5 Derrick Henry +1400
6 Daniel Jones +2000
7 JK Dobbins +3300
8 Jameis Winston +5000
9 Michael Thomas +5500
10 JuJu Smith-Schuster +6600

NFL Comeback Player of the Year Picks and Predictions

Historically, the Comeback Player of the Year has been handed out to mainly quarterbacks. While other positions like safety, tight-ends, running backs have been awarded, the NFL Comeback Player of the Year trends towards quarterbacks.

However, this season many running backs such as Chrisitan McCaffrey, Saquon Barkley, Derrick Henry make their return to the field after suffering season ending injuries.

Check out our expert picks for NFL Comeback Player of the Year below.

10. Daniel Jones (+2000)

While Daniel Jones may not fit the criteria of Comeback Player of the Year, he’ll have a good shot at the award under Brian Daboll.

The Giants are off to a hot start with a 2-1 record. Even though Jones hasn’t had a breakout season, he’s been solid for the Giants.

To his credit, Jones has never been surrounded by a great supporting cast but there might be a higher ceiling for him under Daboll, who’s known for building effective offenses in Buffalo.

If Jones can control his fumble percentage and stay healthy, there may be a chance for the quarterback to win Comeback Player of the Year.

Take Daniel Jones to win Comeback Player of the Year below.

9. Christian McCaffrey (+1200)

Since 2020, Christian McCaffrey has only started in 10 games. He’s had numerous injuries including sprains and strains to both ankles, his shoulders, glutes and hamstrings that have kept him out of the Panther’s backfield.

Before injuries rendered him to the sideline, McCaffrey ran for 1,385 yards and had 1,005 receiving yards in 2018. Since then, McCaffrey has been essentially unseen.

If McCaffrey can serve up a big campaign this season, he would be a surefire vote in for Comeback Player of the Year after missing two seasons.

Take McCaffrey for Comeback Player of the Year below.

8. Khalil Mack (+6600)

Khalil Mack looks to turn a new leaf with the Los Angeles Chargers this season. Mack joins Joey Bosa, Derwin James and J.C Jackson in LA, which gives the Chargers one of the best defensive rosters in the NFL.

Mack is coming off a foot injury that caused him to miss 10 games. He is a strong pass rusher and teaming up with Bosa should make him even more dangerous.

While Mack hasn’t posted double-digit sacks since 2018, he’ll be an integral part of why the Chargers’ defense has a chance to become among the league’s best units.

If Mack can contribute a double-digit sack season and push the Chargers to the top of the AFC West, he’ll be the best bet for Comeback Player of the Year.

7. JK Dobbins (+3300)

The Baltimore Ravens were red hot last season before suffering injuries leading them to miss the playoffs. After star running back J.K Dobbins tore his ACL, the Ravens looked flat footed.

While back up Gus Edwards tried to step up, the Ravens were not able to replicate their explosive ground game.

Before his injury Dobbins has rushed for 828 yards averaging 5.9 yard a carry and has already rushed for nine touchdowns.

He made his debut against the Patriots in Week 3, where he rushed for only 23 yards on seven carries for an average of 3.3 yards. He also added 2 receptions for 17 yards for an average of 8.5 yards a catch.

John Harbaugh looked to strengthen the backfield for Lamar Jackson in the offseason but instead decided to rely on Dobbins in more of a full-time role.

Take JK Dobbins to win Comeback Player of the year at +4000 odds.

6. Michael Thomas (+5500)

When he’s healthy, Michael Thomas is one of the most dominant wide receivers in the game.

Last season was a tough year for the New Orleans Saints with both Michael Thomas and Jameis Winston going down with injuries.

However, if the Saints have a good run this season, Thomas will likely be a major reason why.

So far Thomas is averaging 10.7 yards per catch for 171 yards and 3 touchdowns this season.

Take Michael Thomas to win Comeback Player of the Year.

5. Lamar Jackson (+1200)

One of the key pieces to the Baltimore Ravens offense, Lamar Jackson is simply irreplaceable.

While other key pieces in the Ravens’ offense went down in 2021, Jackson missed a total of six games in the 2021 season due to injury. The Baltimore Ravens went from being the No.1 team in the AFC North to missing out on the postseason.

With Lamar Jackson back in action, the Ravens hope to regain their momentum heading into the regular season.

If Jackson can pull off another spectacular run without skipping a beat, he’d be one of the best candidates to take for Comeback Player of the Year.

4. Jameis Winston (+5000)

For the last five years, quarterbacks have run away with the NFL Comeback Player of the Year award.

If that trend continues, the immediate pick would be Jameis Winston. After getting off to a hot start last season with the New Orleans Saints, Winston tore his ACL in week 7. In just that short period of time, Winston threw for 14 touchdowns and only three interceptions.

While the Saints only have the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to worry about in this division. Winston looks to have made a full recovery after completing 23 passes on 34 attempts for two touchdowns, averaging 7.91 yards per an attempt in week 1.

If the Saints defense is the same as last season, Winston puts New Orleans back into playoff contention.

Take Jameis Winston to win Comeback Player of the Year below.

3. JuJu Smith-Schuster (+6600)

While Juju Smith-Schuster is coming off a shoulder injury, he begins a new chapter in his career with the Kansas City Chiefs. Smith-Schuster is only 25 years old meaning he’s still young enough to jump back with full strength this season.

Smith-Schuster will also be fed by one of the most productive quarterbacks in the league with Patrick Mahommes. In addition, Andy Reid has always been an offensive genius and Smith-Schuster might look better than he’s ever had with the Chiefs.

Take JuJu Smith-Schuster to win NFL Comeback Player of the Year.

2. Derrick Henry (+1400)

Before getting hurt last season, Derrick Henry was on pace to shatter multiple rushing records.

While Henry only started in eight games last season, he still finished the season with the 15th-most overall touches.

Mike Vrabel features a very run-heavy offense and with Henry lining up in the back field, he may have a chance to lead the league in rushing yards once again this season.

Take Henry to win Comeback Player of the Year below.

1. Saquon Barkley(-210)

According to the best US sports betting sites, Saquon Barkley is the favorite to win Comeback Player of the Year at +300 odds.

Barkley has had a stellar beginning of the season. In Week 1 against the Tennessee Titans, Barkley stole the show averaging 9.11 yards per carry on 18 touches. He went on for 164 yards on the ground and a touchdown. Barkley also added 30 receiving yards on six catches.

On the field, it looks like Barkley has regained his explosiveness. His cuts are sharp and his game has elevated looks much better than the last two years.

If Barkley can continue his momentum and the Giants keep on winning, he would be a prime candidate for Comeback Player of the Year.

Take Barkley for the Comeback Player of the Year below before his odds shortened as the season progresses.

When Is NFL Comeback Player of the Year Announced?

All NFL awards including Comeback Player of the Year are announced at the NFL Honors ceremony, the day before the Super Bowl.

A nationwide panel of media personnel votes upon the award. While the NFL Honors have not been officially announced for the 2022-2023 NFL season, football fans can expect the ceremony to happen on February 11, 2023, the day before the Super Bowl.

NFL Comeback Player of the Year Voting

The NFL Comeback Player of the Year award is presented by many media outlets including the Associated Press, Pro Football Writers Association, Sporting News, and United Press International.

Who Won NFL Comeback Player of the Year in 2021?

Joe Burrow of the Cincinnati Bengals Won NFL Comeback Player of the Year.

Burrow suffered a severe knee injury in 2020 and came back to not only win the NFC North but carry the Bengals to the Super Bowl for the first time in 33 years.

List of AP NFL Comeback Player of the Year Winners

Since 2011, the winner has been announced at the annual NFL Honors ceremony, making it the official NFL Comeback Player of the Year Award.

With two NFL Comeback Player of the Year Award victories, Chad Pennington is the only player in NFL history to win the award twice.

Over the last 20 years, the Comeback Player of the year has been given to quarterbacks 14 times. While the award is dominated by quarterbacks, there have been previous positions awarded.

Generally, there aren’t many repeat winnings with the only expectation going to Chad Pennington.

Check out the list of AP NFL Comeback Player of the Year Award winners below.

Year Player Position Team
1963 Jim Martin Kicker Baltimore Colts
Paul Lowe Running back San Diego Chargers
1964 Lenny Moore Running back Baltimore Colts
Abner Haynes Running back Kansas City Chiefs
1965 John Brodie Quarterback San Francisco 49ers
Paul Lowe (2) Running back San Diego Chargers
1966 Dick Bass Running back Los Angeles Rams
Babe Parilli Quarterback Boston Patriots
No award given between 1967 and 1997
1998 Doug Flutie Quarterback Buffalo Bills
1999 Bryant Young Defensive tackle San Francisco 49ers
2000 Joe Johnson Defensive end New Orleans Saints
2001 Garrison Hearst Running back San Francisco 49ers
2002 Tommy Maddox Quarterback Pittsburgh Steelers
2003 Jon Kitna Quarterback Cincinnati Bengals
2004 Drew Brees Quarterback San Diego Chargers
2005 Tedy Bruschi Linebacker New England Patriots
Steve Smith Sr. Wide receiver Carolina Panthers
2006 Chad Pennington Quarterback New York Jets
2007 Greg Ellis Defensive end Dallas Cowboys
2008 Chad Pennington (2) Quarterback Miami Dolphins
2009 Tom Brady Quarterback New England Patriots
2010 Michael Vick Quarterback Philadelphia Eagles
2011 Matthew Stafford Quarterback Detroit Lions
2012 Peyton Manning Quarterback Denver Broncos
2013 Philip Rivers Quarterback San Diego Chargers
2014 Rob Gronkowski Tight end New England Patriots
2015 Eric Berry Safety Kansas City Chiefs
2016 Jordy Nelson Wide receiver Green Bay Packers
2017 Keenan Allen Wide receiver Los Angeles Chargers
2018 Andrew Luck Quarterback Indianapolis Colts
2019 Ryan Tannehill Quarterback Tennessee Titans
2020 Alex Smith Quarterback Washington Football Team
2021 Joe Burrow Quarterback Cincinnati Bengals

Whether you are new to NFL betting or looking for some advanced tips and strategies, you will find something useful here. Here are some of the topics we cover:

Arrow to top